On 10 November, the Industry, Energy and Research Committee (ITRE) in European Parliament adopted its position on FP10, the next EU framework programme for research and innovation (R&I). This marks an important milestone in the Parliament’s proposal for FP10, ahead of a plenary vote, currently scheduled for 23 November, which will determine Parliament’s formal negotiating position.
Parliament’s position seeks to preserve FP10 as an autonomous R&I programme while strengthening its contribution to European competitiveness. Key themes include a larger budget, a strong role for experts in the governance of Pillar II, fewer priorities and Partnerships in Pillar II, and a new ‘trusted partners’ designation. Many of the proposals reflect recommendations in Mario Draghi’s 2024 report on European competitiveness.
Across the programme, Parliament places strong emphasis on scientific excellence, researcher support and investigator-led funding alongside competitiveness objectives.
A Larger Budget
Parliament proposes a budget of €200bn. This is a significant increase compared with the Commission’s proposal (€175bn) and EU Council’s revised October figures (€158bn). Co-rapporteurs of Parliament’s FP10 proposal, Members of European Parliament (MEPs) Christian Ehler and René Repasi, warned against cuts to the programme’s budget, arguing it will harm Europe’s ability to be competitive and resilient.
Pillar I, ‘Excellent Science’
The proposal seeks to safeguard the autonomy and bottom-up nature of the European Research Council (ERC) and Marie Sklodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA). The text also introduces a formalised structured dialogue for the ERC President to engage with the Parliament at least once a year.
The proposal for a ‘Fast Track to Excellence’ remains from the Parliament’s draft reports for FP10. This instrument would support small-scale, bottom-up collaborative research and high-risk, blue-sky science, with a maximum union contribution per research action of €2 million.
Governance of Pillar II, ‘Competitiveness and Society’: Expert-led approach
For Pillar II’s connection with the European Competitiveness Fund (ECF), Parliament maintain separate work programmes for FP10 and ECF and propose to regularly convene joint committee meetings. Therefore, the focus is on coordination of the two instruments rather than integration. This is reflected in Parliament’s proposal for ECF, which proposes coordinated efforts such as Horizon Europe Pathway Actions to deploy, commercialise, scale, license, or standardise research results.
Proposed High-Level Council and Lead Experts
Parliament propose one High Level Council which will consist of at least 30 independent experts from across scientific disciplines and representing science, innovation, industry and civil society. The Commission would appoint experts for up to 4 years, with oversight from the Parliament and Council. Their role will be to advise the Commission and national governments on the broad thematic priorities of the work programmes in Pillar II. Programme committees would continue to approve the work programmes.
The High-Level Council would be supported by Lead Experts, who would be responsible for setting research priorities in work programmes, helping prepare and monitor calls for proposals. One Lead Expert would oversee one work programme. Every 6 months, Lead Experts’ teams would prepare an updated 18-month outlook of planned funding calls.
This contrasts with Parliament’s initial proposal in their draft reports, where they put forward two councils of 15 independent experts whose decisions could only be amended by the Commission in exceptional and justified cases. However, some were concerned that this would give these bodies too much power.
In all, this proposal keeps experts closely involved in the governance of Pillar II, while changing how they are organised and their function.
Pillar II’s Functions
Policy windows and sectoral plans
Parliament’s text details the activities under each Policy Window in the ‘Competitiveness’ element. The ‘Society’ part is also organised into thematic windows covering the green transition; sustainable, inclusive and healthy societies; inclusive digital societies; and resilient societies.
Repasi’s proposal for Sectoral Plans has moved from Pillar I to Pillar II, where €10 million is proposed to pilot this new funding scheme in Social Science, Humanities and Arts Sectoral Plan. Assessment of the pilot will identify the feasibility of extending Sectoral Plans to other disciplines.
Moonshots and Fast Track to Innovation
Moonshots (major strategic research initiatives) are maintained, with Parliament setting out that they should be managed by a Lead Expert and fund bottom-up projects, with more specific calls possible at a later stage. Parliament call for mandatory stakeholder and citizen engagement. The list for moonshot projects diverges to that by the Commission – Parliament put forward women’s health, the effects of environmental exposures on human health (human exposome) and the quantum internet as potential topics.
Parliament proposes Pillar II will support a ‘Fast Track to Innovation’ instrument, supporting small-scale bottom-up collaborative innovation projects up to €2 million for 2 years.
European Partnerships
On European Partnerships, Parliament maintain that they should only be established in exception and duly justified cases where other funding instruments cannot achieve the desired objectives. Parliament proposes a cap of 35 Partnerships at any given time. The Commission has considered scenarios involving 18, 24 or 28 Partnerships. There is currently around 60 Partnerships, and there is consensus to reduce and simplify this, but the details, including portfolio areas, are undecided.
Pillar III, ‘Innovation’
The European Innovation Council (EIC) should become more ARPA-style (US Advanced Research Projects Agency). This describes a high risk, high reward innovation model, targeting breakthrough deeptech innovations. Parliament seeks to achieve this by strengthening the autonomy of EIC, including calling for EIC Programme Managers to have senior positions within the Commission to ensure their freedom.
To improve deployment of research and commercialisation, Parliament state that innovation ecosystems should build synergies with any future EU legal framework that facilitates a pan-European corporate status.
Pillar IV, ‘European Research Area’
Parliament would have two categories for Widening countries: widening and transition countries. Unlike the Commission’s proposal to use the European Innovation Scoreboard to determine these categories, the Parliament favour the criterion of how closely each country is integrated into the European Research Area (ERA). The exact details for how this would be decided is not known.
On research and technology infrastructures, Parliament comment that FP10 should contribute up to 20% of the building costs of critical new worldclass capacities.
Association to FP10: A category for the UK and CH, and Trusted Partners
The Parliament compromise text builds on the existing four categories for association and sets out a fifth category that sets apart the United Kingdom and Switzerland. Both countries are currently in category D with other third countries; this move to segregate the UK and Switzerland from other Category D countries is a novelty for FP10. However, it is unclear from the text what this category might mean in practice and whether it would have tangible impacts on the association process for either country.
Trusted Partner designation
The Parliament text also sets out a novel designation for ‘trusted partners’ in FP10 which can be applied following association. The trusted partner designation sets out clear criteria which an associated country must meet, including:
- a demonstrated track record of sustained and substantive participation in previous Union Framework Programmes for R&I;
- a commitment to freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law and respect for human rights;
- a robust legal and institutional framework for the protection of intellectual property rights, research integrity and personal data;
- and that participation of the associated country does not contravene the strategic interests of the Union or the Member States.
The Trusted Partner designation is likely to confer pre-approved status for participating in certain calls where research topics may be considered sensitive or strategic. This includes those areas where participation is subject to Article 22.5 in the current Framework Programme (for associated countries in FP9, the Commission has deployed Article 22.5 to determine whether a country is eligible to participate in funding calls such as calls in AI and quantum; this assessment is done for each annual Work Programme and the UK has largely been included in these calls since WP2025). The impact of the designation could be greater continuity and predictability enabling partners to plan for long-term collaboration.
Crucially, the Parliament’s proposal for the designation can be revoked, if it was found that an associated country no longer meets one or more of the criteria set out above.
Other notable proposals
On dual-use research, the proposal acknowledges that the distinction between civilian and military applications cannot always be clearly drawn. However, it maintains that FP10 should retain an exclusive focus on civilian R&I activities. The starting point for research should not be defence but if research funded under FP10 subsequently demonstrates relevance for defence applications, funding for that research could continue. This reflects Parliament’s preference to preserve the civilian character, in contrast to the Commission’s proposal for FP10 to be dual-use by default and the Council’s proposal to introduce dedicated dual-use calls.
Includes discipline and country agnostic support for researchers at risk, including a European Fellowship scheme to provide funding for the placement of researchers.
Parliament introduces research security as a cross-cutting priority and a European Research Security Network for awareness raising and to share best practices.
What Happens Next?
The European Parliament’s plenary vote on their FP10 proposal is expected on the 23 November.
Trilogue negotiations between the Parliament, Council and Commission will begin once EU governments have agreed a deal on the overall EU budget for 2028-34, which they hope to achieve by the end of the year. The outcome of this will determine the final structure and ambition of FP10 and the funding available to the programme.